Tonight’s annual general meeting of Melton Borough Council should have been an occasion for reflection and renewal, when a new mayor is elected and the leader of the council gives his state of the borough address. Cllr John Illingworth was sworn in as mayor, promising to hold the ‘dignity of the office’ while speaking for everyone in Melton. Well-wishes were on everyone’s lips, but the consensus didn’t last long. This meeting wasn’t much of a honeymoon for the new mayor, instead it went straight to marriage counseling after becoming one of the most partisan council meetings in recent years.
Leader of the Tories on Melton Borough Council, Cllr Byron Rhodes, wanted to push through a series of constitutional changes that would sideline debate and discussion by axing the Overview and Scrutiny committee. The proposals were pushed through at the last full-council meeting in April, in the face of opposition from Labour Councillors, led by Cllr Matthew O’Callaghan. So when the constitutional amendments were presented as a package again to the council for ratification, it was no surprise that Labour’s Matthew O’Callaghan renewed his attack on the proposals.
Matthew pointed out that the constitution of Melton Borough Council states that
“Changes to the Constitution will only be approved by the Full Council after consideration of the proposal by the Overview, Scrutiny and Audit Committee or by the Monitoring Officer in consultation with the Chair of the Overview, Scrutiny and Audit Committee agreeing that a proposed amendment may be sent direct to Council in respect of minor or urgent amendments.”
Cllr O’Callaghan made the case that the decision to abolish the Overview and Scrutiny committee was itself unconstitutional, as it had not itself been discussed at the Overview and Scrutiny committee. According to Matthew, “Labour has no problem with abolishing any of the committees on Melton Borough Council, but there is a right way of doing things, and this is not the right way.”
Speaking for the majority Tory group, Cllr Rhodes pushed aside these concerns, suggesting that any delay to his changes are simply an opposition trick. Supported by the councils monitoring officer, the new mayor was forced to adjudicate a decision as to the validity of the motion. Taking his advice from the officers, Mayor Illingworth allowed the vote to go ahead, and the constitutional amendments were adopted eighteen votes for and eight votes against.
The next controversial issue came with the allocation of committee members, chairs and other roles. In the past, when Cllr Malise Graham was leader, this has been allocated on the basis of proportion, political balance and consensus. But Cllr Rhodes, however, has different ideas. All of the chairs of committees will be Conservative Councillors, and none of these will be Councillors who represent Melton in a town ward.
“This has become a one party council,” Labour’s Cllr O’Callaghan argued. “All opposition is being pushed aside”. There are now fifteen conservative Councillors in paid posts on Melton Borough Council. More than half of the council is paid an allowance by the Tory leader to carry out their functions. When decisions are made, it seems that Cllr Rhodes will have a firm hand behind every one of them.”This is a winner takes all council” said Cllr O’Callaghan. “Opposition is being pushed aside, and when that happens mistakes are made and decisions are taken that will later be regretted”. After another vote, eighteen for and six against, Mayor Illingworth noted that he had sympathy with many of the comments that were made in the debate and hoped that agreement could be found outside the meeting.
It seems that Melton Borough Council is now firmly split along party lines.